HANA YORI DANGO SEASON 2
-
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Dec 26th, '05, 03:20
- Location: California
HANA YORI DANGO SEASON 2
Should Hana Yori Dango COntinue?
IN my Opinion...I thought the ending scenes from episode 9 showed hints that it will and I do hope that it does because it was definitely short!!!
IN my Opinion...I thought the ending scenes from episode 9 showed hints that it will and I do hope that it does because it was definitely short!!!
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Oct 18th, '05, 19:56
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Aug 6th, '04, 02:10
- Location: Brazil
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 66
- Joined: Jul 16th, '05, 14:20
- Location: Bordeaux - France
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Aug 6th, '04, 02:10
- Location: Brazil
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 4
- Joined: Dec 21st, '05, 12:36
-
- Posts: 533
- Joined: Nov 10th, '05, 07:33
- Location: Canada
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Oct 27th, '05, 00:22
dittomakino_sanbr wrote:You... almost give me a Heart attack!!!
I thought that was some Breaking news
...
But about you question...
I not even neutral about this...
For sure HYD deserve a second season!!!
There is a lot to tell...
^__^
theres going to be a sequel to the manga, so they'll probebly do a sequel to the drama, hopefully
-
- Posts: 67
- Joined: May 28th, '05, 21:10
- Location: USA
The ending of Hana Yori Dango isn't even the ending at all. That's why there is a "See you, soon!" thing at the end.saltylatte wrote:i'm skeptical of a HYD2. just look what they did to MG2...
i rather stick to the ending of HYD. at least it will forever be a cinderella dream.
And the storyline only covers until Volume 12 of the manga there are 24 more volume of storyline to go.
You measure Hana Yori Dango against Meteor Garden 1 and 2. You should measure it againsts the manga or the anime.
Sorry that you felt skeptical, but the fact is, you are jumping to conlusion before actually giving season 2 a chance just because Meteor Garden 2 sucks totally.
Uh.. I've read in the discussion forum for HYD that Kamio-sensei is picking up where she left off with Hana Yori Dango. So the manga isn't over yet.
As for a second season, I highly highly hope that they would have a second season. The last scene of HYD indicates a possibility of a second season. However, I'm hoping that they won't change the cast as they have all grown on me. It would be a damn shame if they change the cast because they had the chemistry, well specifically the main cast. As for the fact that second seasons usually suck, there's always hope that this would be completely different. I mean they did leave a lot of things out from the manga and they could make a second season out of what's left, but it has to be things that make sense when you intertwine them together. Anyway, I wish and hope with all of my heart that a second season is on the way. I would't even mind having to wait a year or two because this drama deserves much patience and time.
As for a second season, I highly highly hope that they would have a second season. The last scene of HYD indicates a possibility of a second season. However, I'm hoping that they won't change the cast as they have all grown on me. It would be a damn shame if they change the cast because they had the chemistry, well specifically the main cast. As for the fact that second seasons usually suck, there's always hope that this would be completely different. I mean they did leave a lot of things out from the manga and they could make a second season out of what's left, but it has to be things that make sense when you intertwine them together. Anyway, I wish and hope with all of my heart that a second season is on the way. I would't even mind having to wait a year or two because this drama deserves much patience and time.
-
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Dec 26th, '05, 03:20
- Location: California
YUP YUP YUP
I DO Toally agree with everything that you guys said in this forum. I do thanks all of you guys who participated in the discussion so far. I do know that Season 2 is on its way. YAY
-
- Posts: 433
- Joined: Nov 14th, '05, 23:02
- Location: Canada
Somehow... I think... we all are hoping for it, though we are afraid... and we are somehow really sure of it too... becaise of this see you soon thing.
Would be horrible oif there won't be a second season after all...
I'm for a second season too. And I believe that there will be one. At least some kind of a special... because the end was just too open.
And I hope that they won't change the cast... not even one person. Cause they all did a gtood job... and I started to like them a lot.
Let's wish for a second season... not a weak one, but a great one!!! ^^
Would be horrible oif there won't be a second season after all...
I'm for a second season too. And I believe that there will be one. At least some kind of a special... because the end was just too open.
And I hope that they won't change the cast... not even one person. Cause they all did a gtood job... and I started to like them a lot.
Let's wish for a second season... not a weak one, but a great one!!! ^^
I would love for there to be a season 2 - however the See You Soon! might not mean that.. I have seen a few other shows I.E. PGSM say the same thing in their last episode - and never see another season or another continuation period. While we are all hopeful, if there is not a second season we shouldn't be too hurt
A 2nd season!? I'm not really too sure about that...I kinda liked the way it ended cuz it shows everyone is happy and ended up with who they wanted to be with. If they do make a 2nd season I hope they don't make it stupid or drag it out. That would really screw it up.
If they make a 2nd season of HYD and make it like the 2nd season of Gokusen, then I'll really be pissed to say the least.
I really didn't like Gokusen 2. I only watched 2 episodes and wasn't happy with it. They had different people, a different school and the story was too much like the 1st one. When I heard there was a Gokusen 2, I thought that Yankumi would follow her students to college and teach them.
Oops, that was way off topic. ><; Sorry. Anyways, If they make a good HYD 2nd season then, I'm all for it. If they make it bad then I'll be just sad.
If they make a 2nd season of HYD and make it like the 2nd season of Gokusen, then I'll really be pissed to say the least.
I really didn't like Gokusen 2. I only watched 2 episodes and wasn't happy with it. They had different people, a different school and the story was too much like the 1st one. When I heard there was a Gokusen 2, I thought that Yankumi would follow her students to college and teach them.
Oops, that was way off topic. ><; Sorry. Anyways, If they make a good HYD 2nd season then, I'm all for it. If they make it bad then I'll be just sad.
-
- Posts: 109
- Joined: Nov 14th, '05, 04:49
Whether they do a special or a proper followup season, it's going to be awhile. The main actor for Hana Yori Dango has signed on to do a movie for spring. HYD drew the highest ratings of the fall schedule, so we're probably going to see some sort of followup.
The finale, which was great, complicated how you do a 2nd season. The TV show covered roughly the first half of the manga, but the ending of the TV show IS the ending of the manga. Adapting the 2nd half of the manga would be very difficult given how this show ended.
The writers of HYD could choose to adapt Kamio's sequel to HYD. Of course, if they do that, we won't see HYD, part 2 for at least a few years.
The finale, which was great, complicated how you do a 2nd season. The TV show covered roughly the first half of the manga, but the ending of the TV show IS the ending of the manga. Adapting the 2nd half of the manga would be very difficult given how this show ended.
The writers of HYD could choose to adapt Kamio's sequel to HYD. Of course, if they do that, we won't see HYD, part 2 for at least a few years.
-
- Posts: 64
- Joined: Oct 24th, '04, 16:17
i really don't understand why people are so scared of a season 2. it's not like gokusen or mg where they had no more material fromt the original work. there's still sooooo much left in hana yori dango the manga that they didn't cover. to make up a totally different thing when you have that much material left is just strange and crazy. also i don't see any reason why they would change the cast. it's a good cast that works really well together. unless the producers are complete idiots, i'm sure the cast will remain the same IF there IS a second season. but then again, you can never tell with people.
i think a second season would be great. Especially since the manga is one of the longest ever and they covered maybe 20% of it (maybe not even...my memory is kinda fuzzy since its been so long since i read it) And didn't everything feel rushed, like tsukushi and tsukasa didn't spend enough time interacting for her to admit that she loved him...? so season 2 would be great...flesh out the fantasy LOL
-
- Posts: 109
- Joined: Nov 14th, '05, 04:49
Perhaps one problem with this adaptation is that it was mostly written with the triangle in mind, whereas the triangle was only one or two arcs in the original manga. But I was extremely happy with the narrative itself; you have to watch some of the episodes a few times to appreciate how dense the adaptation gets. The way themes and character observations were built in parallel, it flows less like a TV serial and more like a long, long movie. In that "movie movie" way, I thought their romance flowed well.And didn't everything feel rushed, like tsukushi and tsukasa didn't spend enough time interacting for her to admit that she loved him...?
I'd imagine getting the 5 actors to reprise their roles won't be easy. They're all going to want more money, they're all going to want the show to fit their schedule, and you'd figure Jun's agency will want to bill him as a main actor on the show.
I'd like to see Kazuma and Shigeru in a 2nd season. Throw the amnesiac arc in and boom, you have a completely fresh story. Upgrade Jun's jeri curls to a J-Fro and you're set!
hmmm i dont think it will be a 2 S for hyd
for some resons
1- if u read the manga u will reconize that the drama took most of the important
events ( japan teen , domyoji mather dirty plans, domuji sister help, the F4
splite, the dirty photos plan ..etc
SO, what the 2S will add to the drama ? u remamber losing memory and some
bad events? i was so happy that they remove it from the drama and by the way
the manga ending is the worse ever it left me very sad but the drama its an opening
and happy ending , makino said i love you << finally
2- in the manga the mother force domyuji to go to NY and he didnt see makino
but in the drama we saw that the mother became more kind and they saw each
other before they seperate.
3- the mother in the manga play dirty untile the very end she accept makina
if domyuji complete his studies and carry the family busnez.
the drama encloded this event so whats left for the 2 S am wondering?!!
waiting for your ideas
for some resons
1- if u read the manga u will reconize that the drama took most of the important
events ( japan teen , domyoji mather dirty plans, domuji sister help, the F4
splite, the dirty photos plan ..etc
SO, what the 2S will add to the drama ? u remamber losing memory and some
bad events? i was so happy that they remove it from the drama and by the way
the manga ending is the worse ever it left me very sad but the drama its an opening
and happy ending , makino said i love you << finally
2- in the manga the mother force domyuji to go to NY and he didnt see makino
but in the drama we saw that the mother became more kind and they saw each
other before they seperate.
3- the mother in the manga play dirty untile the very end she accept makina
if domyuji complete his studies and carry the family busnez.
the drama encloded this event so whats left for the 2 S am wondering?!!
waiting for your ideas
I agree that they use the actual final of the manga in the dorama
it looks to me that if they do a second part they will totally mess with the manga order
more than they already did
coz they show tha manga in a horrible order
they mix from here and there
I really hated that
I really don`t understand why is this the most high rating dorama
it was an ok for me only for the first 3 episodes and the last one
and because of Shun as Rui character
it looks to me that if they do a second part they will totally mess with the manga order
more than they already did
coz they show tha manga in a horrible order
they mix from here and there
I really hated that
I really don`t understand why is this the most high rating dorama
it was an ok for me only for the first 3 episodes and the last one
and because of Shun as Rui character
-
- Posts: 109
- Joined: Nov 14th, '05, 04:49
-
- Posts: 106
- Joined: Mar 19th, '05, 14:35
I am desparately hoping they would have a season2 or as least a special... maybe like after tsukasa comes back to japan after his studying in NY!!! I just can't get enough of Jun & Mao.. they make the best couple =) and I really want to see more of Makino saying sweet things to Tsukasa (like in the manga- Makino says things like "don't leave me" "i love you" etc and she kissed him. not tsukasa kissed her)
-
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Dec 9th, '05, 01:58
- Location: The OC
-
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Dec 26th, '05, 03:20
- Location: California
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Aug 6th, '04, 02:10
- Location: Brazil
- Contact:
I don't agree..Aisling wrote:I agree that they use the actual final of the manga in the dorama
it looks to me that if they do a second part they will totally mess with the manga order
more than they already did
coz they show tha manga in a horrible order
they mix from here and there
I really hated that
I really don`t understand why is this the most high rating dorama
it was an ok for me only for the first 3 episodes and the last one
and because of Shun as Rui character
And you can put me on the side of hardcore HYD manga fans.. really I'm obsessed...
I have some difficult s On he first time that i watched every ep...
But then i could see... HYD essential was there.
And to tell the true if Yoko Kamio that is the author, didn't complain...
Why i will?
If they had chance the essential.. i would be really piss of..
Like put tsukushi and Rui together...
This Definitely NOT Hana Yori Dango..
Or make Domyouji fall in love for another girl... ( I would not mention that is in MG2 )
But i missed so much some parts too...
And i feel that could came back a little to show this parts...
If they could do this 9 ep, I'm sure that they would do a good job on the others events...
But i agree that the end is pretty much the same arc as the manga end.
everyone has to admit we were all disappointed when we found out it was only 9 episodes. it'd make sense now to have a short season if there were ones to follow.
i haven't finished reading the mangas yet (and to anyone who hasn't you should pick them up... soooo amazing) but i already agree w/ the majority that THERE SHOULD BE A S2!! there is just soo much more to the story!
i haven't finished reading the mangas yet (and to anyone who hasn't you should pick them up... soooo amazing) but i already agree w/ the majority that THERE SHOULD BE A S2!! there is just soo much more to the story!
First, I want a second season too.
What`s so wrong about mixing the manga-storyline ? They can take things they left out in the first season into the second season. It would be more worst when the drama ending wouldn`t fit at all just because they exactly followed the manga and made us wait for the next season just to continue the story.
And maybe it was just 9 eps because the actors had signed other contracts and the whole storyline had to be re-planned because of those circumstances.
Don`t think too much about things that are unclear or could end negative. Look forward the dramas coming out next year bringing us joy !!
What`s so wrong about mixing the manga-storyline ? They can take things they left out in the first season into the second season. It would be more worst when the drama ending wouldn`t fit at all just because they exactly followed the manga and made us wait for the next season just to continue the story.
And maybe it was just 9 eps because the actors had signed other contracts and the whole storyline had to be re-planned because of those circumstances.
Don`t think too much about things that are unclear or could end negative. Look forward the dramas coming out next year bringing us joy !!
This is my first reply to a subject and also the fact that English isn't my native language makes me beg you to ignore mistakes
to the topic
In the Matsumoto Jun Thread there was mentionned that he might play soon in another live act of a manga with the short name "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" (I love my younger sister)......
It may be just a rumor but regarding the fact that he already played in 3 live acts based on manga, it's not impossible!
But if it's true it would mean he can't play Tsukasa so there won't be S2 or and which is even more terrible they'll make a S2 without him (nnnnnnnoooooooooo!!!!!!)
On the other hand it would be really fun to see him play Yori from "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" who has a crush on his younger twin sister Iku and really wants her to love him too and even to do that kind of things that a normal couple do.....
Yori is a quite passionate guy and everyone who like MatsuJun who probably be excited to see him playing this role....it's sad that the story of this manga isn't really deep.
Well to be honest this doesn't really bring the diskussion on but I found it interesting to mention...
After all a Happy New Years Eve to all of you!!
to the topic
In the Matsumoto Jun Thread there was mentionned that he might play soon in another live act of a manga with the short name "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" (I love my younger sister)......
It may be just a rumor but regarding the fact that he already played in 3 live acts based on manga, it's not impossible!
But if it's true it would mean he can't play Tsukasa so there won't be S2 or and which is even more terrible they'll make a S2 without him (nnnnnnnoooooooooo!!!!!!)
On the other hand it would be really fun to see him play Yori from "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" who has a crush on his younger twin sister Iku and really wants her to love him too and even to do that kind of things that a normal couple do.....
Yori is a quite passionate guy and everyone who like MatsuJun who probably be excited to see him playing this role....it's sad that the story of this manga isn't really deep.
Well to be honest this doesn't really bring the diskussion on but I found it interesting to mention...
After all a Happy New Years Eve to all of you!!
I didn't like this story ..How would a guy fall iin love with his sister?!! That's Nonsence!Steffchef wrote:This is my first reply to a subject and also the fact that English isn't my native language makes me beg you to ignore mistakes
to the topic
In the Matsumoto Jun Thread there was mentionned that he might play soon in another live act of a manga with the short name "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" (I love my younger sister)......
It may be just a rumor but regarding the fact that he already played in 3 live acts based on manga, it's not impossible!
But if it's true it would mean he can't play Tsukasa so there won't be S2 or and which is even more terrible they'll make a S2 without him (nnnnnnnoooooooooo!!!!!!)
On the other hand it would be really fun to see him play Yori from "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" who has a crush on his younger twin sister Iku and really wants her to love him too and even to do that kind of things that a normal couple do.....
Yori is a quite passionate guy and everyone who like MatsuJun who probably be excited to see him playing this role....it's sad that the story of this manga isn't really deep.
Well to be honest this doesn't really bring the diskussion on but I found it interesting to mention...
After all a Happy New Years Eve to all of you!!
i heard that there is a sequel to the manga. if there is a sequel to the manga there SHOULD also be a sequel to the live-action one. and about replacing the characters? I will not support that! i won't watch it either if they have a second season with different characters. I love Jun as Tsukasa and Mao as Makino too much!
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Aug 6th, '04, 02:10
- Location: Brazil
- Contact:
Steffchef wrote:This is my first reply to a subject and also the fact that English isn't my native language makes me beg you to ignore mistakes
to the topic
In the Matsumoto Jun Thread there was mentionned that he might play soon in another live act of a manga with the short name "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" (I love my younger sister)......
It may be just a rumor but regarding the fact that he already played in 3 live acts based on manga, it's not impossible!
But if it's true it would mean he can't play Tsukasa so there won't be S2 or and which is even more terrible they'll make a S2 without him (nnnnnnnoooooooooo!!!!!!)
On the other hand it would be really fun to see him play Yori from "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" who has a crush on his younger twin sister Iku and really wants her to love him too and even to do that kind of things that a normal couple do.....
Yori is a quite passionate guy and everyone who like MatsuJun who probably be excited to see him playing this role....it's sad that the story of this manga isn't really deep.
Well to be honest this doesn't really bring the diskussion on but I found it interesting to mention...
After all a Happy New Years Eve to all of you!!
well seem that is true that Matsujun will be on a movie based on "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru" ...
I Don't really know.. but i think that if even they make a Hanada special..will take some time..
I started to read "Boku wa Imouto ni Koi wo Suru"... and to tell the true.. i didn't liked..
Was too much for me.. I stopped in ch 07...
Well.. will only be good because probably will have some hot bed scenes... ( *_* matsujun!!!!! ahhhhhTotally a fangirl...)
Yoko Kamio will work again in HYD... but if the Drama follow this continuation will take more time probably
Watching the last episode made me want a season 2 as well BUT when they... I knew they were going to finish the series there. There was closure. Makino That was it. Also, I think the reason it only ran 9 episodes was because they hired big name actors and actresses who have other projects in line in their career. I don't think they'd commit to long series so a HYD2 is unlikely to happen.
I don't want a second season bcuz the major stuff already happened in the drama..so I guess making a new season for it with a new plot and stupid things to seperate them would only drag the story even more >.>
so I guess having just a special episode would be great loved gokusen 1's special episodes,it was like the real ending for season one...so I'd love it if they could make one like that for Hana Yori Dango
so I guess having just a special episode would be great loved gokusen 1's special episodes,it was like the real ending for season one...so I'd love it if they could make one like that for Hana Yori Dango
-
- Posts: 53
- Joined: Nov 27th, '05, 00:08
- Location: Irvine, California
hmm.. LoL, i've changed my opinion. as i read more and more of the series i've really decided maybe a second season might not be so good. it could possibly be good.. but the ending of the first season definitely did give closure. it was merely a short moment... but it still counts.
I'm happy and content with only getting one season of hana yori dango.
I'm happy and content with only getting one season of hana yori dango.
-
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Aug 6th, '04, 02:10
- Location: Brazil
- Contact:
You can get HYD manga by bittorrent:jaccie wrote:well does anyone of you know where to get Hana Yori Dango's manga scanlations??? Im looking high and low for it .. hana yori dango is one of my fav anime of all times!!
http://www.boxtorrents.com/details.php?id=11772
Manga http://www.animez.info/torrents.html
Manga http://www.mybittorrent.com/info/bittor ... 14442.html
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Dec 30th, '05, 22:34
- Location: Arcriff Temple =D
Meteor Garden had a second season because they finished MG1 waaay before the manga ended.yakusoku92 wrote:i think there will be seeing how meteor garden had a second season
which explains why season 2 sucked very badly--because they stretched the 3 remaining volumes to quite a number of episodes.
you remember yesha's character? she's only appeared for a short period of time and she didn't play a very significnt role in the last few volumes. and domiyouji's character just had amnesia for a few days (around less than a week). not much drama and drag-fest. hehe
hated MG 2...
Last edited by kko_lit on Jan 2nd, '06, 13:39, edited 1 time in total.
- wing_wing1
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Nov 20th, '05, 01:42
- Location: manchester
- Contact:
yeah me too... i can't wait to see the sequel.. ora at least a special..
btw, i'm learning to make animated gif and here's my 1st creation..
images credit to The Saturn Necklace
btw, i'm learning to make animated gif and here's my 1st creation..
images credit to The Saturn Necklace
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Jan 6th, '06, 07:48
- Location: Canada
- Contact:
yeah that long distance type ending sux.zany003 wrote:I don't think they need to make a 2nd season since there is closure. But if they do, I hope Makino and Domyouji actually hook up in the end (no long distance kinda stuff). It shouldn't be sloppy, either.
I hope theyll make season 2...and i also hope that it wont be like in Gokusen ...1 season great, 2nd sux
-
- Fansubber
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Apr 20th, '04, 01:34
- Location: BC, Canada
- Been thanked: 2 times
- Contact:
^^It doesn't suck. IMO, if Gokusen 2 was aired before Gokusen 1, or if u watch it w/o seeing season 1...then it would have been treated more kindly by the internet viewers...coz if u checked out the ratings from viewers in Japan...0_o, they were shockingly high.garnet07 wrote:Uhh sorry for being off topic, but is Gokusen 2 worth watching. Well I finished watching Gokusen 1 and that was a great drama. The thing is they ended it perfectly ( like the students actually graduated and stuff) so should I download Gokusen 2. I mean is it worth it???
It is still funny...but I find myself fast forwarding the fights, and Yankumi's speeches, coz they're almost duplicated, except for some very few revisions.
What's nice though, as somebody pointed out to me, is that there's lots of "eye-candy", as u call 'em, I mean, just imagine Jin, Kame, Mokomichi and that cute little guy whose name I forgot...all in one package..hahaha...but...BUT, I still loveee Sawada and the gang much, much, better...simply because, nothing beats the original...(most of the time).
I would have stopped midway, if it was realllyy bad...I can't believe I've reached ep10...so I guess it's alright.
I heard SARS are working on it, so if ur planning to watch it, then u could wait for their releases.
Kyaaaaaaaaaaaa!
Woah, what was that... a sequel to the manga you say. Tell me more tell me more!
and a second season would kick ass...
if they stick with the same cast...
and don't destroy the season with some random plot...
stick with same cast...
stick with same cast...
stick with same cast...
ok repetitive but still heartfelt...don't want another Gokusen 2 (Sawada where'd ya go!)
3 cheers 4 Hana Yori Dango (and Jun)
*cheer*
*cheer*
*cheer*
and a second season would kick ass...
if they stick with the same cast...
and don't destroy the season with some random plot...
stick with same cast...
stick with same cast...
stick with same cast...
ok repetitive but still heartfelt...don't want another Gokusen 2 (Sawada where'd ya go!)
3 cheers 4 Hana Yori Dango (and Jun)
*cheer*
*cheer*
*cheer*
- hana_k1Ta_____!
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Jan 11th, '06, 11:46
- Location: STHLM
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests