Full House or My Girl ? (BASHA , AJAJA FIGHTING!)
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
Full House or My Girl ? (BASHA , AJAJA FIGHTING!)
For me I would be sure to choose My Girl . Lee Da-Hae and Lee Dong Wook are just too cute together . All of the acotrs and actresses in there did a great job. I think My Girl is kind of similar to Full House in the beginning so I just want to see the number of votes on which one you would choose? I really dislike Full House so yeahh.... My parents like My Girl too
Full House:
Details
Title: 풀하우스 / Pool Ha-woo-seu
Episodes: 16
Broadcasted by: KBS
Broadcast year: 2004-07-14 to 2004-09-02
Cast
Bi (Rain) as Lee Young Jae
Song Hye Gyo as Han Ji Eun
Han Eun Jung as Kang Hye Won
Kim Sung Soo as Yu Min Hyuk
[edit]Synopsis
A naive, cheerful albeit, somewhat of a recluse writer, Ji Eun (Song Hye Gyo) is swindled out of everything she owns. Not by strangers, but her best friends! Stranded in another country, she is determined to get home, only to find that all which is precious to her has been sold. In an attempt to get her possessions back, she has "sell her soul."
A story about love and heartbreak, sadness and self-preservation. In spite of it all, Ji Eun manages to be humorous and endearing - even when her heart is breaking
If you guys have pics feel free to post it on .
My Girl:
Title: 마�?�걸 / ma-i-geol
Genre: Romance, Comedy
Episodes: 16
Broadcast network: SBS
Broadcast period: 2005-12-14 to 2006-??-??
Air time: Wednesday & Thursday 9:55 PM
Synopsis
Female swindler makes her way to the top, but finds love along the way.
more (http://www.soompi.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=17032)
Cast
Lee Da Hae
Lee Dong Wook
Park Si Yeon
Lee Jun Ki
[img]http://img288.imageshack.us/img288/4861 ... 8456kw.jpg[/img]
[img]http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/7120 ... 9at6eo.jpg[/img]
[img]http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/7773 ... 8457cv.jpg[/img]
[img]http://img288.imageshack.us/img288/5876 ... 844530.jpg[/img]
Full House:
Details
Title: 풀하우스 / Pool Ha-woo-seu
Episodes: 16
Broadcasted by: KBS
Broadcast year: 2004-07-14 to 2004-09-02
Cast
Bi (Rain) as Lee Young Jae
Song Hye Gyo as Han Ji Eun
Han Eun Jung as Kang Hye Won
Kim Sung Soo as Yu Min Hyuk
[edit]Synopsis
A naive, cheerful albeit, somewhat of a recluse writer, Ji Eun (Song Hye Gyo) is swindled out of everything she owns. Not by strangers, but her best friends! Stranded in another country, she is determined to get home, only to find that all which is precious to her has been sold. In an attempt to get her possessions back, she has "sell her soul."
A story about love and heartbreak, sadness and self-preservation. In spite of it all, Ji Eun manages to be humorous and endearing - even when her heart is breaking
If you guys have pics feel free to post it on .
My Girl:
Title: 마�?�걸 / ma-i-geol
Genre: Romance, Comedy
Episodes: 16
Broadcast network: SBS
Broadcast period: 2005-12-14 to 2006-??-??
Air time: Wednesday & Thursday 9:55 PM
Synopsis
Female swindler makes her way to the top, but finds love along the way.
more (http://www.soompi.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=17032)
Cast
Lee Da Hae
Lee Dong Wook
Park Si Yeon
Lee Jun Ki
[img]http://img288.imageshack.us/img288/4861 ... 8456kw.jpg[/img]
[img]http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/7120 ... 9at6eo.jpg[/img]
[img]http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/7773 ... 8457cv.jpg[/img]
[img]http://img288.imageshack.us/img288/5876 ... 844530.jpg[/img]
MY GIRL, MY GIRL...
I can't watch Full House, because I don't like Song Hye Kyo's character, quite stupid...sorry, my mean is she is so funny, why always believe of her friend, while they are cheated her a lot...No one can be nice like that.....
I love the Yoo Rin's character...so cute...funny and strong !
I can't watch Full House, because I don't like Song Hye Kyo's character, quite stupid...sorry, my mean is she is so funny, why always believe of her friend, while they are cheated her a lot...No one can be nice like that.....
I love the Yoo Rin's character...so cute...funny and strong !
I liked MG over FH. FH was good, but around episode six, it really started to get on my nerves. By the time I got to the final episodes, I was glad it was over. It's a good story, but I wanted to strangle both the girls and stab the guy in the face with a spoon. Yeah, I know... graphic, but still... I couldn't just stop watching it cause I did wnat to know how it ended, but I do believe they coudl have made the story better. It isn't like they weren't onto something gold, but it was like the writer or the director or someone lost their track halfway through the drama.
MG has been the best drama I've seen, period. I can't stay it will be the last best one I'll see, but for now, it's #1. The director and actors did their best to bring that story to life. Perhaps the director (same director?) learned from the mistakes in FH and other dramas and put in the extra effort into bringing it to life. If I remember correctly, the director did Delightufl Girl too. I watched that series after I finished ep 14 of MG -- not knowing they were actually related -- and I can see where the director fixed his mistakes in DGCH. Another solid drama, but it dragged on too like FH but not in the same way or direction.
So... That is long enough.
MG has been the best drama I've seen, period. I can't stay it will be the last best one I'll see, but for now, it's #1. The director and actors did their best to bring that story to life. Perhaps the director (same director?) learned from the mistakes in FH and other dramas and put in the extra effort into bringing it to life. If I remember correctly, the director did Delightufl Girl too. I watched that series after I finished ep 14 of MG -- not knowing they were actually related -- and I can see where the director fixed his mistakes in DGCH. Another solid drama, but it dragged on too like FH but not in the same way or direction.
So... That is long enough.
full house was the second kdrama i watched and i really loved it i have watched it twice so far but if i had to choose between that or my girl. it would have to be my girl hands down, as much as i loved full house and the story and everything that went into it, i really enjoyed my girl which got me back onto kdrama and then palace (but that's another topic) i loved everything about my girl from the cast to the story it made me laugh, really pulled at my heart strings and i couldn't wait for the next episode so my vote goes to my girl
-
- Posts: 47
- Joined: Nov 7th, '05, 20:12
- Location: Colorado
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 199
- Joined: Mar 23rd, '05, 01:47
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
-
- Posts: 43
- Joined: Sep 20th, '05, 22:46
- Location: Florida
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 433
- Joined: Nov 14th, '05, 23:02
- Location: Canada
IMO My Girl is better than Full House Full House was cute at first, but I got tired of it towards the end when SHK just seemed to have lost her fighting spirit; she was all teary-eyed and listless for the longest time.
Now Yoo-rin was different in My Girl, she had spunk and was strong. There was a particularly moving scene when she broked down and wailed her lungs out.. but even after the separation from Gong-chan.. she did not mope around but instead got on with her life.. as cheerful & spunky as ever Just gotta love her character
Now Yoo-rin was different in My Girl, she had spunk and was strong. There was a particularly moving scene when she broked down and wailed her lungs out.. but even after the separation from Gong-chan.. she did not mope around but instead got on with her life.. as cheerful & spunky as ever Just gotta love her character
-
- Fansubber
- Posts: 811
- Joined: Apr 29th, '05, 23:42
- Location: S. Cali
i'd definitely say My Girl over Full House. i don't know...i never really got into Full House like so many others. i got very tired of the "i'm moving out!" scenes and the temper tantrums...and it wasn't that funny. My Girl was funny throughout. even when it was sad, there was always something humorous that made you feel cheerful again...the lies that YooRin told were funny and she had great chemistry with the two male leads. i think the two dramas tie for the most annoying 2nd female lead.
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Dec 27th, '05, 08:20
- Location: California, USA
definitely MY GIRL--the drama has everything: humor, chemistry between the two main protagonists, sad and heart-touching moments; Gond Chan's & Yoo Rin's relationship is more memorable than Young Jae's and Ji Eun's relationship.
on the other hand, i love FULL HOUSE too, but it gets draggy near the end; especially when it's already established that Young-Jae wants to marry Ji Eun for reals and has to propose...yet Ji Eun doesn't accept when she's DUH in love with the man.
another level of comparison is that the male protagonist in MY GIRL makes my heart flutter, whereas I only fell for Bi's smile in Full House. Joo Yoo Rin's and Ji Eun's cuteness level is about the same so I won't compare the two--i adore both.
on the other hand, i love FULL HOUSE too, but it gets draggy near the end; especially when it's already established that Young-Jae wants to marry Ji Eun for reals and has to propose...yet Ji Eun doesn't accept when she's DUH in love with the man.
another level of comparison is that the male protagonist in MY GIRL makes my heart flutter, whereas I only fell for Bi's smile in Full House. Joo Yoo Rin's and Ji Eun's cuteness level is about the same so I won't compare the two--i adore both.
-
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Feb 4th, '05, 03:15
- Location: USA
For me, I personally loved both equally. Both series provided funny and great romantic chemistry. Full House definitely had the better-looking love rival though. *God, I love Kim Sung Su* And the other rival (who's name escapes me at the moment) was kind of too persistant even though he was in a In case that was a spoiler (though I don't know why a person who hasn't seen the full series would be voting on this), I spoilered it out for you. Both series also have equal amounts of comedy and drama. But what came down to the defining moment for me was the love confession kisses.
Bi and Song Hye Kyo had this tight-lipped, anti-climactic kiss that I was unsatisfied with. But Lee Dong Wook and Lee Da Hae had this really good kiss. It was emotional and real compared to the Full House couple.
That's just my take on it - and this is putting aside my indifference for Bi. I think he did a good job on Full House.
Bi and Song Hye Kyo had this tight-lipped, anti-climactic kiss that I was unsatisfied with. But Lee Dong Wook and Lee Da Hae had this really good kiss. It was emotional and real compared to the Full House couple.
That's just my take on it - and this is putting aside my indifference for Bi. I think he did a good job on Full House.
hands down to MY GIRL!!!
i liked full house--but after watching delightful girl, mnikss--full house was ok..
and rewatching full house-->i realized that bi n shg just bicker the whole drama..some ppl love that--but too much--it was too painful to watch over n over again...
with my girl--the writer did an excellent job to make every epi exciting..and i can say i can after rewatching my girl--i never get tired of it!!!
i liked full house--but after watching delightful girl, mnikss--full house was ok..
and rewatching full house-->i realized that bi n shg just bicker the whole drama..some ppl love that--but too much--it was too painful to watch over n over again...
with my girl--the writer did an excellent job to make every epi exciting..and i can say i can after rewatching my girl--i never get tired of it!!!
-
- Posts: 40
- Joined: Feb 15th, '06, 09:59
azndgn26 wrote:lol, yes...that is scaryAtomic wrote:Definately Full House..
The chick from My Girl reminded me of a turtle.. She seriously needs to sit up straight, or stand up straight cause her crouching especially when she's wearing a turtle neck freaks me out.
She's pretty and all.. but the clothes they had her wear wasn't suitable for her.. plus the way her posture during the scenes just reminded me of a turtle or an old grandmother.. PLEASE GOD SHOW ME YOUR NECK AND STOP CROUCHING. It got to the point where I'd actually stop watching the show and just stare at her posture/neck thinking.. WTF are they thinking making her wear that...
^turtle? i thought she looked more like a mouse in some eps., but i found it funny instead of scary haha..actually i wasnt too crazy about some of her kooky wardrobe either, but i think her acting surpassed her fashion sense, and her clothes got prettier as the series progressed, no?
anyways, My Girl was all around better imo:
good cast- i thought they all were ok at first, but now i really like LDH and LDW , great characters-SPOILERthe male lead treated the girl well B4 he fell for her, and he always redeems himself after making her sad, o ya and it seems every of her snowy *b-day* something cute happens betw them, the girl stayed strong and didnt lose her spirit halfway like so many other dramas..ahem FH.., she's always retaliating when someone mistreats her: sexually harrasses a lady and blames GC or throws the brick in a chicken suit, classic , the supporting lead actor didnt turn super evil and remained cool w/ his friend, and overall: minimal heartbreak/ misunderstandings(except for 2nd male lead, but i didnt really care for him.. ) .and most of all good plot/pace- every episode was relevant and entertaining, (the ending was way too quick tho! =/ ), just the right mix of romance, humor, and drama..i teared up when the grandpa confronted her
..lol sorry i went on and on, but this series is really freakin good!
--->as for FH, it had a cute cast, some funny scenes, but i think why the spunky girl loved the jerk wasn't justified...in fact i liked the similar story portrayed in Attic Cat better ..but if u like either star, its a good watch to satisfy ur inner fangirl..bi's smile is so disarming, and shk is always gorgeous.
anyways, My Girl was all around better imo:
good cast- i thought they all were ok at first, but now i really like LDH and LDW , great characters-SPOILERthe male lead treated the girl well B4 he fell for her, and he always redeems himself after making her sad, o ya and it seems every of her snowy *b-day* something cute happens betw them, the girl stayed strong and didnt lose her spirit halfway like so many other dramas..ahem FH.., she's always retaliating when someone mistreats her: sexually harrasses a lady and blames GC or throws the brick in a chicken suit, classic , the supporting lead actor didnt turn super evil and remained cool w/ his friend, and overall: minimal heartbreak/ misunderstandings(except for 2nd male lead, but i didnt really care for him.. ) .and most of all good plot/pace- every episode was relevant and entertaining, (the ending was way too quick tho! =/ ), just the right mix of romance, humor, and drama..i teared up when the grandpa confronted her
..lol sorry i went on and on, but this series is really freakin good!
--->as for FH, it had a cute cast, some funny scenes, but i think why the spunky girl loved the jerk wasn't justified...in fact i liked the similar story portrayed in Attic Cat better ..but if u like either star, its a good watch to satisfy ur inner fangirl..bi's smile is so disarming, and shk is always gorgeous.
-
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Mar 13th, '06, 14:42
Atomic wrote:azndgn26 wrote:lol, yes...that is scaryAtomic wrote:Definately Full House..
The chick from My Girl reminded me of a turtle.. She seriously needs to sit up straight, or stand up straight cause her crouching especially when she's wearing a turtle neck freaks me out.
She's pretty and all.. but the clothes they had her wear wasn't suitable for her.. plus the way her posture during the scenes just reminded me of a turtle or an old grandmother.. PLEASE GOD SHOW ME YOUR NECK AND STOP CROUCHING. It got to the point where I'd actually stop watching the show and just stare at her posture/neck thinking.. WTF are they thinking making her wear that...
Totally agree with u guys... but i still love her
-
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Dec 19th, '05, 16:55
- Location: U.A.E
Definitely My Girl! Before watching this show, Full House was my favorite mainly because of Bi's smile. But after seeing My Girl, that changed.
I love Yoo Rin's character! She's strong, confident, funny, cute, etc. and she doesn't let anyone mess with her and get away with it. Love Gong Chan's character too. can he get anymore perfect?!
By the way, now that you mention Yoo Rin's "crouch posture" and "mouse face" I realized even more how great of an actress Lee Da Hae is. It is these little details that she adds to her roles that distinguish her characters from one series to the next. I'm watching Green Rose and seen her on specials and her posture is not that. Definitely signatures of Ju Yoo Rin.
BHASHYA!
I love Yoo Rin's character! She's strong, confident, funny, cute, etc. and she doesn't let anyone mess with her and get away with it. Love Gong Chan's character too. can he get anymore perfect?!
By the way, now that you mention Yoo Rin's "crouch posture" and "mouse face" I realized even more how great of an actress Lee Da Hae is. It is these little details that she adds to her roles that distinguish her characters from one series to the next. I'm watching Green Rose and seen her on specials and her posture is not that. Definitely signatures of Ju Yoo Rin.
BHASHYA!
Definitely My Girl !!! Bashyaaa .. I love Yoorin's character. I agree w/ some of u, her posture is annoying somehow, but I dont mind since i think dats hows her Yoorin's character is .. not perfect, but dorky and weird ahha cuz i saw her in other dramas and she wasn't like dat. I love LDK's character ... its like .. he's funny at the right time, serious at the right time .. not beeing too serious and suddenly becomes funny .. and I love Jun ki's character tooooo ... i just love My Girl. I watched Full House too .. i enjoy My Girlll
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
She doesn't look short . She's probably in the medium not too skinny not too fat lol so maybe that's why and plus she was crounching in My Girl too because she's suppose to do that for her role. If you compare her with Go Soo in Green Rose you'll change your mind right away plus she's not wearing HIGH HEELS Look. Go Soo is 1.78m :JoSungMo wrote:Lee da hae is truely beautiful. BTW she looks short but she's actually 170cm/almost 5'8" tall.
[img]http://img359.imageshack.us/img359/2852 ... ose7mu.png[/img]
WOW so many people chosing My Girl...
For me Full House wins easily. My Girl was great and all but compared to Full House it was boring and short, plus Bi and Song Hye Gyo were definitely a better couple. Sure Lee Dong Wook + Lee Da Hae were a cute couple and all but there's no way Lee Da Hae can be compared with Song Hye Gyo and Bi compared with Lee Dong Wook; their characters (in the dramas) or their looks.
Lee Da Hae is cute...but Song Hye Gyo is in another league all together (as in G-O-D-L-Y).
LOL, And Bi is definitely cuter than Lee Dong Wook. I wasn't sure about how different in age they made Song Hye Gyo and Bi look at first but there's parts like near the end when they went shopping and bought ice cream and stuff where they just looked perfect.
For me Full House wins easily. My Girl was great and all but compared to Full House it was boring and short, plus Bi and Song Hye Gyo were definitely a better couple. Sure Lee Dong Wook + Lee Da Hae were a cute couple and all but there's no way Lee Da Hae can be compared with Song Hye Gyo and Bi compared with Lee Dong Wook; their characters (in the dramas) or their looks.
Lee Da Hae is cute...but Song Hye Gyo is in another league all together (as in G-O-D-L-Y).
LOL, And Bi is definitely cuter than Lee Dong Wook. I wasn't sure about how different in age they made Song Hye Gyo and Bi look at first but there's parts like near the end when they went shopping and bought ice cream and stuff where they just looked perfect.
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
WOW My Girl is in the lead big time >
Last edited by Sunshine_36 on Mar 14th, '06, 00:14, edited 2 times in total.
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
I disagree with you I think Lee Da-Hae looks prettier than Song Hye Kyo in body, acting wise . Plus Lee Da-Hae looks more lively on her interviews especially when she smiles > Lee Dong Wook has a nicer face than Rain in my opinion but Rain has a better body .Horizon wrote:WOW so many people chosing My Girl...
For me Full House wins easily. My Girl was great and all but compared to Full House it was boring and short, plus Bi and Song Hye Gyo were definitely a better couple. Sure Lee Dong Wook + Lee Da Hae were a cute couple and all but there's no way Lee Da Hae can be compared with Song Hye Gyo and Bi compared with Lee Dong Wook; their characters (in the dramas) or their looks.
Lee Da Hae is cute...but Song Hye Gyo is in another league all together (as in G-O-D-L-Y).
LOL, And Bi is definitely cuter than Lee Dong Wook. I wasn't sure about how different in age they made Song Hye Gyo and Bi look at first but there's parts like near the end when they went shopping and bought ice cream and stuff where they just looked perfect.
LOL Rain doesn't have a great face when you look at it from certain angles or when he has bad hair days (he seems to have had a lot in the past) but when he's animated (as in in a video) he's pretty cute...in a childish sort of way. Especially his facial expression.
In My Girl i think Lee Dong Wook looked a mess to be honest, that stuble looked nasty, ick. But usually yeah i'd say he looks better than Bi...in a dashing sort of way.
In My Girl i think Lee Dong Wook looked a mess to be honest, that stuble looked nasty, ick. But usually yeah i'd say he looks better than Bi...in a dashing sort of way.
Last edited by Horizon on Mar 14th, '06, 00:28, edited 2 times in total.
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
Yes, but I admit that Rain acts better than LDW although I think LDH acts better than SHK in Full House .Horizon wrote:LOL Rain doesn't have a great face when you look at it from certain angles or when he has bad hair days (he seems to have had a lot in the past) but when he's animated (as in in a video) he's pretty cute...in a childish sort of way. Especially his facial expression.
In My Girl i think Lee Dong Wook looked a mess to be honest, that stuble looked nasty, ick. But usually yeah i'd say he looks better than Bi...in a dashing sort of way.
LOL actually i think LDH's role in My Girl was really easy for her, all she had to do was act either crazy (which she is in real life) or extremely sad. Infact all she had to do was act extremely sad in Green Rose as well.
Song Hye Gyo has done a much wider variety of roles and after watching them including her early works i can tell you she's extremely versitile.
Well anyway i don't wanna turn this into some kind of sad fan argument that never goes anywhere
Song Hye Gyo has done a much wider variety of roles and after watching them including her early works i can tell you she's extremely versitile.
Well anyway i don't wanna turn this into some kind of sad fan argument that never goes anywhere
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
Naa I don't think it's an argument I just think we're giving our ideas . But keep in mind that SHK has acted for along time and wait until LDH goes to success.Horizon wrote:LOL actually i think LDH's role in My Girl was really easy for her, all she had to do was act either crazy (which she is in real life) or extremely sad. Infact all she had to do was act extremely sad in Green Rose as well.
Song Hye Gyo has done a much wider variety of roles and after watching them including her early works i can tell you she's extremely versitile.
Well anyway i don't wanna turn this into some kind of sad fan argument that never goes anywhere
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
-
- Posts: 42
- Joined: Feb 28th, '06, 23:21
- Location: USA
-
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Mar 11th, '06, 00:53
- Location: In BoBoLand!
Agreed! I kept thinking that too I def. choose Full house over My Girl, even though I saw MG first and enjoyed and all, I was a little bored w/the end and after a while the soundtrack started to annoy me (like Jeong-woo's theme ::shiver:: )Fullhouse is certainly the original and I found myself laughing more, especially at Bi's sneaky smirks >w<SlightlyTempted wrote:Full House definitely..........Young Jae & Ji Eun remind me of the characters in Goong....
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests