Moon Geun Young vs Liu Yi Fei
Moon Geun Young vs Liu Yi Fei
I first watched Moon Geun Young in Autumn Tale which she probably filmed when she was around 12-13 years old. I was quite impressed by her acting and I was really impressed by her in My Little Bride & Innocent Steps. When I first watched Liu Yi Fei, it was in Chinese Paladin, and she played the leading female role, which is really impressive. 15 years old and landed on a leading role in a legend series which got quite famous. After that, she still went on carrying leading roles in more legendary series, like woah . They both started their acting careers in such big films at such a young age yet they pulled it off leaving a great impression of themsleves afterwards. I've watched them both in many films and they're both great actresses. They're pretty much around the same age and they remind me of each other cuz they both have that young baby face.
So the question is which do u prefer based on their acting skills?
Moon Geun Young
[img]http://xb7.xanga.com/40db44e5d963043031 ... 186204.jpg[/img]
[img]http://x6e.xanga.com/7cab54f65263143031 ... 186203.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xc6.xanga.com/7b2b57e5c903143031 ... 186108.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xb6.xanga.com/5b481b534314843031 ... 186101.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xde.xanga.com/871b55e52823143031 ... 186096.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xdf.xanga.com/badb76e42053343032 ... 186587.jpg[/img]
Moon Geun Young's Series/Movies
Autumn Tale
Lover's Concerto
My Little Bride
A Tale of Two Sisters
Innocent Steps
Crystal Liu Yi Fei
[img]http://xa4.xanga.com/82aa97547603143029 ... 142057.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xc5.xanga.com/7168144b4410843031 ... 186202.jpg[/img]
[img]http://x81.xanga.com/e2cb57e65753143029 ... 185250.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xdc.xanga.com/c77b76e6d333343029 ... 185247.jpg[/img]
[img]http://x03.xanga.com/612b7be6c303243029 ... 185242.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xa4.xanga.com/46bb40ea5613043029 ... 185240.jpg[/img]
Crystal Liu Yi Fei's Series
Story of a Noble Family [Jin Fen Shi Jia]
Chinese Paladin [Xian Jian Qi Xia Zhuan]
Love of May
The Love Winner
Heavenly Dragon the Eighth Episode 2003 [Tian Long Ba Bu 2003]
Return of the Condor Heroes 2006 [Shen Diao Xia Lv 2006]
So the question is which do u prefer based on their acting skills?
Moon Geun Young
[img]http://xb7.xanga.com/40db44e5d963043031 ... 186204.jpg[/img]
[img]http://x6e.xanga.com/7cab54f65263143031 ... 186203.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xc6.xanga.com/7b2b57e5c903143031 ... 186108.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xb6.xanga.com/5b481b534314843031 ... 186101.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xde.xanga.com/871b55e52823143031 ... 186096.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xdf.xanga.com/badb76e42053343032 ... 186587.jpg[/img]
Moon Geun Young's Series/Movies
Autumn Tale
Lover's Concerto
My Little Bride
A Tale of Two Sisters
Innocent Steps
Crystal Liu Yi Fei
[img]http://xa4.xanga.com/82aa97547603143029 ... 142057.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xc5.xanga.com/7168144b4410843031 ... 186202.jpg[/img]
[img]http://x81.xanga.com/e2cb57e65753143029 ... 185250.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xdc.xanga.com/c77b76e6d333343029 ... 185247.jpg[/img]
[img]http://x03.xanga.com/612b7be6c303243029 ... 185242.jpg[/img]
[img]http://xa4.xanga.com/46bb40ea5613043029 ... 185240.jpg[/img]
Crystal Liu Yi Fei's Series
Story of a Noble Family [Jin Fen Shi Jia]
Chinese Paladin [Xian Jian Qi Xia Zhuan]
Love of May
The Love Winner
Heavenly Dragon the Eighth Episode 2003 [Tian Long Ba Bu 2003]
Return of the Condor Heroes 2006 [Shen Diao Xia Lv 2006]
Last edited by azndgn26 on Mar 18th, '06, 19:04, edited 3 times in total.
lol, what are you talking about Ssang? Moon Geun Young is EXTREMELY PRETTY.
BUT Liu Yi Fei is just picture perfect, she is just way too pretty in the whole martial arts get-up. The Moment you see her it's like...wow. Seriously, she's like an angel. And her smile is just @_@ , well let's just say it'd give Lee Hyo-Ri's smile a run for its money.
Acting-wise i'd definitely say Moon Geun Young is better, but Liu Yi Fei is just too pretty on camera. Since they're both pretty i'd say acting should be the main factor but come on...Liu Yi Fei is just @_@ well for me she wins on beauty alone.
BUT Liu Yi Fei is just picture perfect, she is just way too pretty in the whole martial arts get-up. The Moment you see her it's like...wow. Seriously, she's like an angel. And her smile is just @_@ , well let's just say it'd give Lee Hyo-Ri's smile a run for its money.
Acting-wise i'd definitely say Moon Geun Young is better, but Liu Yi Fei is just too pretty on camera. Since they're both pretty i'd say acting should be the main factor but come on...Liu Yi Fei is just @_@ well for me she wins on beauty alone.
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
Re: Moon Geun Young vs Liu Yi Fei
[quote="azndgn26"]I first watched Moon Geun Young in Autumn Tale which she probably filmed when she was around 12-13 years old. I was quite impressed by her acting and I was really impressed by her in My Little Bride & Innocent Steps. When I first watched Liu Yi Fei, it was in Chinese Paladin, and she played the leading female role, which is really impressive. 15 years old and landed on a leading role in a legend series which got quite famous. After that, she still went on carrying leading roles in more legendary series, like woah . They both started their acting careers in such big films at such a young age yet they pulled it off leaving a great impression of themsleves afterwards. I've watched them both in many films and they're both great actresses. They're pretty much around the same age and they remind me of each other cuz they both have that young baby face.
So the question is which do u prefer based on their acting skills?
Actually, you're missing LYF's first series called 金粉世家(don't know the english title) done at the age of 14, fresh from the US with zero acting experience/training. Basically picked off the streets if you will and thrown into this industry. Note, she was also not the main female lead, just a major supporting character.
here's a pic, if it works.
as for MGY.. loved her in many of her works.. in fact, one of the reasons Autumn was so well received was due to her.. you could say she practically made SHK.. as all the feelings for the character transferred from her to the older version... sadly, everyone will only remember SHK for Autumn more then they'll remember MGY.
So the question is which do u prefer based on their acting skills?
Actually, you're missing LYF's first series called 金粉世家(don't know the english title) done at the age of 14, fresh from the US with zero acting experience/training. Basically picked off the streets if you will and thrown into this industry. Note, she was also not the main female lead, just a major supporting character.
here's a pic, if it works.
as for MGY.. loved her in many of her works.. in fact, one of the reasons Autumn was so well received was due to her.. you could say she practically made SHK.. as all the feelings for the character transferred from her to the older version... sadly, everyone will only remember SHK for Autumn more then they'll remember MGY.
- Attachments
-
- 0147.jpg (17.82 KiB) Viewed 7224 times
yeah dan99..
there are some discussion about this drama even have pic in it at Crystal Liu Yi Fei... thread.. so check it out..
there are some discussion about this drama even have pic in it at Crystal Liu Yi Fei... thread.. so check it out..
ah, didn't know.. I was just bored and browsing threads really.. I've seen the series. I didn't like it though, not because of the cast or anything.. it was simply cause I disliked the era it played out in.. so I couldn't really get into the story at all due to that reason.skachild wrote:yeah dan99..
there are some discussion about this drama even have pic in it at Crystal Liu Yi Fei... thread.. so check it out..
its ok..dan99 wrote:ah, didn't know.. I was just bored and browsing threads really.. I've seen the series. I didn't like it though, not because of the cast or anything.. it was simply cause I disliked the era it played out in.. so I couldn't really get into the story at all due to that reason.skachild wrote:yeah dan99..
there are some discussion about this drama even have pic in it at Crystal Liu Yi Fei... thread.. so check it out..
just to let ur know hehe....
never watch that drama bfore... don think i will watch it in the future
coz LYF definitely will act in more drama in the future....
Re: Moon Geun Young vs Liu Yi Fei
thx fer the info I never knew...dan99 wrote:Actually, you're missing LYF's first series called 金粉世家(don't know the english title) done at the age of 14, fresh from the US with zero acting experience/training. Basically picked off the streets if you will and thrown into this industry. Note, she was also not the main female lead, just a major supporting character.
-
- Posts: 224
- Joined: Dec 14th, '04, 23:07
- Location: The Netherlands
defenitely liu yi fei!!
a few pics^^
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei07.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei06.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei05.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei03.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei02.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei01.jpg[/img]
a few pics^^
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei07.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei06.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei05.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei03.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei02.jpg[/img]
[img]http://www.filel0dge.com/files/room16/4 ... ifei01.jpg[/img]
-
- Posts: 224
- Joined: Dec 14th, '04, 23:07
- Location: The Netherlands
this is production from the acting school that LYF in..dan99 wrote:actually.. now that I think about it.. there was another one called 豆蔻年华, I don't know exactly when she did it, but the the role was so minor that it can be considered more of a cameo then an actual role.
many artists from that school are guest stars for the show,
LYF was one of them,
she was an office asistant, something like that...
-
- Posts: 24
- Joined: Nov 14th, '05, 03:26
- Location: Canada
-
- Posts: 244
- Joined: Dec 10th, '05, 16:01
- Location: Middle Ages
LOL. I KNOW, HUH?Sunshine_36 wrote:I don't think it only asks for beauty but acting too because the poll ask "who's better?"
it's funny because a lot of people are superficial and tend to judge celebrities by their looks. it's not a bad and definitely not a good thing, but it just happens =_=;
ehh... i wouldn't say that. she's not drop-dead gorgeous, but she's still pretty in her own way. she's a good actress, too. i haven't seen LYF, so i'm going undecided. what's the point in voting if you can't answer the question?
-
- Fansubber
- Posts: 70
- Joined: May 21st, '06, 06:11
Oops... I didn't read carefully before voting...
I thought its a look vs look thingy... and immediately I vote for Liu Yi Fei...
I think she's a beautiful lady, more than MGY....
But, If I were to read first before voting, I will vote for MGY instead... because the OP is asking for who acts better and imo, MGY acting skills is better than LYF...
I have watched LYF in Chinese Paladin and Condor Heroes.
her acting is bad in Chinese Paladin, I find her annoying there, don't know if its her lack in acting skills or thats what the director wants her to act... I just find her anoying there.
But I love her in Condor Heroes, her acting skills has definitely improved but still lose to MGY....
I dunno why.. just felt something is missing in her character... but acting skill can be matured, further more, she's still young... no offence to LYF fans..
I do find her very pretty though... the most beautiful actress in mainland China imo....
For MGY, first see her acting in Autumn, then in Little Bride and another movie about dancing, forgot the title. Superb acting skills... love her as well.... ^o^
Each has their own uniqueness.... ^o^
Btw, OP, why need to compare these 2?
I thought its a look vs look thingy... and immediately I vote for Liu Yi Fei...
I think she's a beautiful lady, more than MGY....
But, If I were to read first before voting, I will vote for MGY instead... because the OP is asking for who acts better and imo, MGY acting skills is better than LYF...
I have watched LYF in Chinese Paladin and Condor Heroes.
her acting is bad in Chinese Paladin, I find her annoying there, don't know if its her lack in acting skills or thats what the director wants her to act... I just find her anoying there.
But I love her in Condor Heroes, her acting skills has definitely improved but still lose to MGY....
I dunno why.. just felt something is missing in her character... but acting skill can be matured, further more, she's still young... no offence to LYF fans..
I do find her very pretty though... the most beautiful actress in mainland China imo....
For MGY, first see her acting in Autumn, then in Little Bride and another movie about dancing, forgot the title. Superb acting skills... love her as well.... ^o^
Each has their own uniqueness.... ^o^
Btw, OP, why need to compare these 2?
Haha.. i agree with you too much to not say anything. LYF might not be the best new actress, but she's definitely a hot one. MGY was abit annoying in Autumn Fairy Tale, and she still has the kiddy look everytime I look at her, whereas LYF can look sexy whenever she wants. (MGY beats LYF in acting at this point hands down, but I'll be the judge of that later on.)YangYu wrote:LYF is very pretty....why compete her with other who can't win against her???@_@
LYF's debut album isn't so bad either. She's got lots of room for improvements there.
Last edited by crossvii on Sep 6th, '06, 17:08, edited 2 times in total.
-
- Fansubber
- Posts: 364
- Joined: Apr 4th, '05, 00:39
- Location: the southern west coast :]
-
- Posts: 119
- Joined: May 24th, '06, 03:29
hahah...What too pretty to be on screen? then what should she be on? in heaven with the gods???...u guys crack me up...Horizon wrote:lol, what are you talking about Ssang? Moon Geun Young is EXTREMELY PRETTY.
BUT Liu Yi Fei is just picture perfect, she is just way too pretty in the whole martial arts get-up. The Moment you see her it's like...wow. Seriously, she's like an angel. And her smile is just @_@ , well let's just say it'd give Lee Hyo-Ri's smile a run for its money.
Acting-wise i'd definitely say Moon Geun Young is better, but Liu Yi Fei is just too pretty on camera. Since they're both pretty i'd say acting should be the main factor but come on...Liu Yi Fei is just @_@ well for me she wins on beauty alone.
what she's too pretty that she's gonna crack the cameras or something? hahahah
everyone acts like LYF is the only actress with beauty...there are way more beautiful actresses who possess both talents and beauty...and yet they don't get any praises for it..
i find it quite intriquing..that LYF a former graduate from acting school still sucks at acting...yea sure she's young...but everyone who was train from school and still couldn't act isn't an excuse for me...
MYG on the other hand is not as pretty but she's cute..and talented...and i admire her for that...nothing beats talents..
geunyoung!
although Liu Yi Fei got the prettier face, i still vote for Moon Geun Young. I also first saw her in Gaenghul Donghwa, and err. She was 14 when she played that role. I really idolize geunyoung onni.
hahah...What too pretty to be on screen? then what should she be on? in heaven with the gods???...u guys crack me up...
what she's too pretty that she's gonna crack the cameras or something? hahahah
everyone acts like LYF is the only actress with beauty...there are way more beautiful actresses who possess both talents and beauty...and yet they don't get any praises for it..
i find it quite intriquing..that LYF a former graduate from acting school still sucks at acting...yea sure she's young...but everyone who was train from school and still couldn't act isn't an excuse for me...
MYG on the other hand is not as pretty but she's cute..and talented...and i admire her for that...nothing beats talents..[/quote]
i ABSOLUTELY agree.
what she's too pretty that she's gonna crack the cameras or something? hahahah
everyone acts like LYF is the only actress with beauty...there are way more beautiful actresses who possess both talents and beauty...and yet they don't get any praises for it..
i find it quite intriquing..that LYF a former graduate from acting school still sucks at acting...yea sure she's young...but everyone who was train from school and still couldn't act isn't an excuse for me...
MYG on the other hand is not as pretty but she's cute..and talented...and i admire her for that...nothing beats talents..[/quote]
i ABSOLUTELY agree.
wah, for me lyf is very talented, plus she was too pretty like what the previous post mention. If you have been watch her movie, you will definetely say she was talented plus elegent..
Come on, the other actress not pretty at all, k? She just cute, i can say.... If you want me to make choice, i definetely choose lyf because she really have her own stail to catch ppl attention.. OMG hope that i can meet girl as pretty as her...
Come on, the other actress not pretty at all, k? She just cute, i can say.... If you want me to make choice, i definetely choose lyf because she really have her own stail to catch ppl attention.. OMG hope that i can meet girl as pretty as her...
I PERSONALLY THINK lyf IS JUST OVERRATED BY OTHERS WITH WHAT THEY CALL HER "BEAUTY" WHICH I REALLY CAN'T FIND...I FIND SOMETHING ANNOYING BOUT HER AND SHE DOESN'T SEEM TO BE THAT FRIENDLY AT ALL...YES---NOT EVEN TO HER FANS, I DON'T KNOW WHY BUT I MUST FIND OUT...I DON'T EXACTLY FIND HER GORGEOUS, JUST A LITTLE PRETTY MAYBE...AND MOST DEFINITELY NOT A GOOD ACTRESS AS WELL ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU COMPARE HER TO TAIWANESE ACTRESS ARIEL LIN...THAT'S HER, MEANWHILE Moon Geun Young IS AN ACTING-BASED POPULAR CELEB... I DO HOPE YOU GET WHAT I MEAN AND IN KOREA, MOST PEOPLE FIND HER REALLY BEAUTIFUL BUT FOR ME SHE'S CUTE AND HER BODY HAS DVELOPED INOT A MORE VOLUPTUOUS ONE COMPARED TO liu yi fei's ANOREXIC-LOOKING BODYAND IT HAS BEEN PROVEN TO BE UNDER THE NORMAL WEIGHT...I'M SORRY BUT MY EYES WON'T LIE TO ME...lyf IS PURE MAKEUP AND STUFF, MOST OF ALL SHE LOOKS TOO OLD FOR HER 'SUPPOSED AGE"...ACTING ISN'T VERY VERSATILE ENOUGH TOO,SHE JUST PLAYS ANCIENT SERIES WHICH I THINK YOU COULD PUT ANY POPULAR DOLL FROM THE STORE AT THE MOMENT, DRESS IT UP IN ANCIENT CLOTHING AND MAKE IT STAND THERE--THAT IS THE KIND OF ACTING SHE DOES, YOU SEE???..I KNOW I'D GET TOTALLY BASHED BY lyf fans BUT REALLY, WHEN YOU CHOOSE AN IDOL OR VOTE FOR ANYONE IN POLLS LIIKE THIS, YOU SHOULD ALLL BE CAREFUL... AND TO TELL YOU HONESTLY, I'M NOT AT ALL A FAN OF EITHER OF THEM...THIS IS JUST A PURE REACTION...
PS..
I KNEW VERY WELL WHY THESE TWO DIFFERENT CELEBS ARE BEING COMPARED...ITS BECAUSE OF THEIR YOUNG AGE AS WELL AS THEIR HUGE & QUITE SIMILAR RANGE OF POPULARITY..
SO THERE...
PS..
I KNEW VERY WELL WHY THESE TWO DIFFERENT CELEBS ARE BEING COMPARED...ITS BECAUSE OF THEIR YOUNG AGE AS WELL AS THEIR HUGE & QUITE SIMILAR RANGE OF POPULARITY..
SO THERE...
-
- Posts: 268
- Joined: Sep 20th, '08, 16:41
- Location: highest peak on Planet Nibiru
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Mar 31st, '11, 07:49
- Location: Bulacan,Philippines
I'm addicted fan of liu yifei since 13 and i'm now 18.
But I prefer to vote moon geun young..rather than yifei.
moon geun young is a great actress
when she act you will see different emotion.
and when shes happy her eyes suddenly
twinkle...
for yifei she is also a good actress
her act is more on being innocent woman.being
serious and simply..unlike moon
she was more on crying,happy and most of all
i like about her is her way of being stubborn...
but always remember korean movie/series is diff. in chinese
But I prefer to vote moon geun young..rather than yifei.
moon geun young is a great actress
when she act you will see different emotion.
and when shes happy her eyes suddenly
twinkle...
for yifei she is also a good actress
her act is more on being innocent woman.being
serious and simply..unlike moon
she was more on crying,happy and most of all
i like about her is her way of being stubborn...
but always remember korean movie/series is diff. in chinese
i prefer crystal
for natural beauty i prefer crystal,she have the look and also talented,is aint easy to play classic series such return of the confdor heroes,shes still young when play on return of the condors heroes,mean while her partner huang xiao ming is older than her,but she can act and play profesional......she also do the martial art,she play different character on her movie,and what amaze me she can acting so profesional with jacky chan and jet li on international movie forbidden kingdom.....she dont stop improving her act skill,remembering she so young and can go international......its because her act,not only her beautiful face......
in other hand miss geun young also talented,is her passion since her was little,all of her drama and movie (except marry stay out all night) very good.......why i said except mmm,so sorry to said this,her acting on those drama failed,and not suit to her.....as mary she doesnt explore much,flat and no emotion on it......well over all im neutral,and trying observe all the posting in here...
vietchic wrote: I will definitely have to pick MGY!! I love
hmmmmmmm....miss crystal also have the innocence face,she so cute in any kind of role,and most important is in young age she can go international,that was mgy cant do untill now......even mgy carier is drop now,no news from her acept bad news......no offense here but,for some comment that make mgy like the only one actress who can acting,they forget bout one thing shes career stuck only on korea.....comparing with young actress on korea mgy is far away from them,,,,,so sorry giving this fact,but that what happen on the reallity........she also have arrogant personality,rejected drama series moon embracing the sun just because the lead man not famous,,,,,i think she will regret it now,cuz moon embracing the son have spectacular rate on korea and out of korea......good actress will respect other new comer,and having nice personality......her agent is to busy clarification bout her bad news,and for mgy her self dunno what shes doing now,catch up the failed graduation i think LOL....
try watching marry stayed out all night,her acting very flat,and she even got bad opinion from drama critics,she doesn't suit play as marry.....and the rate is going down,so it can take the point,not all her drama is good and not drama she can act good.......she only suit play sad drama,that her skill......
I can never understand the reason behind creating such threads that has no outcome but causing hatred between two sides fans. I know this thread was created years back and I used to see lots of comparison topics back then and not much these day but I also feel that we should let them die out and buried and don't dig them out again.
issy
i just read this thread monday,decided to make account and leave comment after reading all the comment,i can say that most peoples here are mgy fans.......trying to be neutral,and giving fact bout mgy recent news......like i said she surely can acting,but only for sad drama,it prove when she play as marry she failed......what im trying to say here,be open minded........beside mgy korean actreess also good in act,but i can see every thread,and talk bout mgy comparing with other the fans will said of course mgy is the best bla bla bla........thats why i always say to my self hello not only mgy who can act....... thats it my opinion....
I have nothing against your personal opinion as you are totally entitled to have them and I am not MGY fan (total apposite to be precise) so I am not defending her. But as I said these type of comparison threads has no constructive out come and only makes fans dislike each other for no reason. If you ask me I say lock every X vs Y thread on DA.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests