Banner Link Competition RESULTS
-
- Administrator
- Posts: 1150
- Joined: Dec 6th, '03, 00:57
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 6 times
Banner Link Competition RESULTS
Ok the moderators are currently judging all the banners that were submitted for the competition (its hard because there's so many good ones) but I want to do this kinda like Kouhaku style where the public vote is counted as 2 judges votes
So list the banners that you like in this topic and rank them from 1 to 10. You don't have to pick 10 but 10 is the maximum and you must rank them so I can assign points to them. I will add up all the points at the end to get a final top 10 public list. That final list will be counted as 2 moderator votes.
Entrants can vote but can't vote for themselves.
Don't create duplicate accounts just to vote, if we catch you doing it you're banned.
Voting will end after 16th January so you have 5 days.
A list of all entries can be found here http://www.d-addicts.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=10629
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The results are in. I've added up the moderator's vote and the public voting and the result is:
WINNER
puccakiss79
I decided to have 2 runner ups because it was close.
RUNNER UP 1
Kaitler
RUNNER UP 2
Artemis
Thanks to everyone that participated in the competition. There were many good designs submitted and we will certainly be keeping many of them as official d-addicts's banner links.
So list the banners that you like in this topic and rank them from 1 to 10. You don't have to pick 10 but 10 is the maximum and you must rank them so I can assign points to them. I will add up all the points at the end to get a final top 10 public list. That final list will be counted as 2 moderator votes.
Entrants can vote but can't vote for themselves.
Don't create duplicate accounts just to vote, if we catch you doing it you're banned.
Voting will end after 16th January so you have 5 days.
A list of all entries can be found here http://www.d-addicts.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=10629
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The results are in. I've added up the moderator's vote and the public voting and the result is:
WINNER
puccakiss79
I decided to have 2 runner ups because it was close.
RUNNER UP 1
Kaitler
RUNNER UP 2
Artemis
Thanks to everyone that participated in the competition. There were many good designs submitted and we will certainly be keeping many of them as official d-addicts's banner links.
Last edited by Ruroshin on Jan 20th, '05, 22:26, edited 4 times in total.
The summary topic is complete I think. I added the rest of the banners earlier this afternoon so I could look at all the banners at one shot.
Oh, I'd also like to point out that you can group a whole set of a person as one entry. Set, in this case, referring to banners that are similar in style, but alter only in pictures/color.
Oh, I'd also like to point out that you can group a whole set of a person as one entry. Set, in this case, referring to banners that are similar in style, but alter only in pictures/color.
can entrants vote? if so, here's are my favorites:
** edited ranked votes **
1.
Yomy Chan
2. Kaitler
3. puccakiss79
4. bluemiruku
5. jholic
**needs to be cleaned up a little but the concept is very cool
** edited ranked votes **
1.
Yomy Chan
2. Kaitler
3. puccakiss79
4. bluemiruku
5. jholic
**needs to be cleaned up a little but the concept is very cool
Last edited by NatNat on Jan 12th, '05, 06:17, edited 2 times in total.
- Kaitler's second set of banners
- Pale-MuN's set of banners
- pucca's season banner
- Kaitler's first set of banners
- Artemis' banner
- Starlitedr3amer's standard banner
- Kai Lien's banner
- saii06's banners (they're all variations of black and white, so they count as a set, right?)
- NatNat's third type of banner
- ShaolinMunky's 4th type of banner
(dude, ShaolinMunky made the best quotes ever )
Last edited by Carn on Jan 12th, '05, 05:24, edited 3 times in total.
-
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Dec 26th, '04, 22:05
Good job, all entrees...
1. zaza_tk87
2. puccakiss79
3. bluemiruku (definitely worth the wait)
(edit. If I could spell I'd be dangerous someone once said ...wate hmmmpf)
(only no. 3 cause of size but dang this is nice work)
4. ShaolinMunky
5. tv_addict
6. snanime
7. Kaitler
8. NatNat
9. Kai Lien
Voted and done... break a leg everyone.
After all it's the media and performance industry.
1. zaza_tk87
2. puccakiss79
3. bluemiruku (definitely worth the wait)
(edit. If I could spell I'd be dangerous someone once said ...wate hmmmpf)
(only no. 3 cause of size but dang this is nice work)
4. ShaolinMunky
5. tv_addict
6. snanime
7. Kaitler
8. NatNat
9. Kai Lien
Voted and done... break a leg everyone.
After all it's the media and performance industry.
Last edited by techie on Jan 12th, '05, 05:16, edited 2 times in total.
o_o wow.. xD lol~ someone has actually voted for me~ Thank You, you guys~ Here are my choices~
I did it by banners, so a member's name might appear more than once.. xD
1. yangkuang
2. neonkinpatsu
3. babyguh
4. NatNat
5. puccakiss79
6. Starlitedr3amer
7. yangkuang
8. Yashiro
9. MemeX
10. Starlitedr3amer
Great banners everyone, by the way~ Participation is an awesome thing~
I did it by banners, so a member's name might appear more than once.. xD
1. yangkuang
2. neonkinpatsu
3. babyguh
4. NatNat
5. puccakiss79
6. Starlitedr3amer
7. yangkuang
8. Yashiro
9. MemeX
10. Starlitedr3amer
Great banners everyone, by the way~ Participation is an awesome thing~
-
- Geinou
- Posts: 295
- Joined: Aug 22nd, '04, 06:22
- Location: Canada
A lot of effort and time was put into all of the entries. All the entrants should be proud of their work.
Here's my picks:
[1] puccakiss79
[2] animetama
[3] zaza_tk87
[4] sana
[5] zaza_tk87
[6] babyguh
[7] osora
[8] techie
[9] jholic
Good luck to all.
Edit: For some reason, I either missed some entries, or some have been added, so I added an extra pick to my list.
Here's my picks:
[1] puccakiss79
[2] animetama
[3] zaza_tk87
[4] sana
[5] zaza_tk87
[6] babyguh
[7] osora
[8] techie
[9] jholic
Good luck to all.
Edit: For some reason, I either missed some entries, or some have been added, so I added an extra pick to my list.
Last edited by LittleGreenGrasshopper on Jan 13th, '05, 22:56, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 672
- Joined: Dec 20th, '03, 09:32
- Location: Philadelphia, PA
- Contact:
Ok, by the way, I just made what I hope is the final update to the entry summary post. A couple were missed. >__<
Anyway, everyone did SO WELL. It's really hard to pick My top picks:
#1 Natnat
#2 BlueMiruku
#3 Kaitler
Any of them.
#4 Natnat
#5 zaza_tk87
#6 Pucca
#7 BlueMiruku
That was soooo hard ;___; So many good ones!!
Anyway, everyone did SO WELL. It's really hard to pick My top picks:
#1 Natnat
#2 BlueMiruku
#3 Kaitler
Any of them.
#4 Natnat
#5 zaza_tk87
#6 Pucca
#7 BlueMiruku
That was soooo hard ;___; So many good ones!!
- kali4niaguy
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sep 28th, '04, 19:00
- Location: :D
to all the contestants, great job. i wish i had the patience and talent to make 1.
1. zaza_tk87
2. puccakiss79
3. Kaitler (i wish this 1 was colored)
4. puccakiss79
5. ShaolinMunky
6. ShaolinMunky (3 cute actresses on 1 banner, y not!???:mrgreen: )
7. techie
8. NatNat
9. NatNat (the font's so drama-ish, had to include it )
10. BlueMiruku (the guy in the pic isn't my cup of tea, but the animation of D-Addicts is really good).
phew, that was a tough choice, hope i didn't put mix up the banner and creator. good luck to all the contestants.
1. zaza_tk87
2. puccakiss79
3. Kaitler (i wish this 1 was colored)
4. puccakiss79
5. ShaolinMunky
6. ShaolinMunky (3 cute actresses on 1 banner, y not!???:mrgreen: )
7. techie
8. NatNat
9. NatNat (the font's so drama-ish, had to include it )
10. BlueMiruku (the guy in the pic isn't my cup of tea, but the animation of D-Addicts is really good).
phew, that was a tough choice, hope i didn't put mix up the banner and creator. good luck to all the contestants.
There are some great entries. I only voted for my top three, but there were heaps I liked. Some looked good, but I wasn't keen on the slogan. Sometimes it was the other way around. I think Kaitler has the best combination of all the elements: look, 'D-addicts' is easily readable, colour choice, snappy slogan. I really like the slogan 'Got drama?' by the way.
Okay here are my votes:
I have to agree with kali4niaguy - I wish this one was in colour:
1. Kaitler
2. Yomy Chan
3. Pale-MuN
(sorry yangkuang!) I definitely vote against this next one, not because it's bad - it looks great and is well made - but because with the Asian women + pillow + no visible clothes, it looks like a porn site ad:
Okay here are my votes:
I have to agree with kali4niaguy - I wish this one was in colour:
1. Kaitler
2. Yomy Chan
3. Pale-MuN
(sorry yangkuang!) I definitely vote against this next one, not because it's bad - it looks great and is well made - but because with the Asian women + pillow + no visible clothes, it looks like a porn site ad:
-
- Posts: 450
- Joined: Jan 22nd, '04, 16:39
Ruro, I'd like to suggest that the final version used NOT be an animated gif. It's too intrusive and feels too much like an ad banner. It's very distracting to focus on what you want to look/read when there's this dance/flashing banner above.
I'd also like to suggest that the final version used not have actors/actresses in it. Otherwise it ends up looking like another fangirl/fanboy spamming banner advertising for their favorite actor/actress/drama series. The final banner used for the site should be as neutral as possible.
With those two above specifications in mind, there's really only one banner I'd like to vote for:
1. puccakiss79
Pucca's version here is very neutral and not-flashy. Won't damage our eyes while browsing.
I'd also like to suggest that the final version used not have actors/actresses in it. Otherwise it ends up looking like another fangirl/fanboy spamming banner advertising for their favorite actor/actress/drama series. The final banner used for the site should be as neutral as possible.
With those two above specifications in mind, there's really only one banner I'd like to vote for:
1. puccakiss79
Pucca's version here is very neutral and not-flashy. Won't damage our eyes while browsing.
^ BT - I think you made the same mistake in understanding that I did. Up until two days ago, I didn't realize that these banners were being used as advertisement, not to replace the original banner. They're supposed to be links others can use to link back to the d-addicts site, so flashy etc would be, in this case, a good thing. From that aside, I agree with you that I like pucca's banner best. It's so prettiful.
-
- Administrator
- Posts: 1150
- Joined: Dec 6th, '03, 00:57
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 6 times
Um...it is an ad banner. This is not a banner to be used by d-addicts.com these are gonna be banners that other people might like to use when they want to link to d-addicts.com.BT-Slut wrote:Ruro, I'd like to suggest that the final version used NOT be an animated gif. It's too intrusive and feels too much like an ad banner. It's very distracting to focus on what you want to look/read when there's this dance/flashing banner above.
I'd also like to suggest that the final version used not have actors/actresses in it. Otherwise it ends up looking like another fangirl/fanboy spamming banner advertising for their favorite actor/actress/drama series. The final banner used for the site should be as neutral as possible.
Ruroshin wrote:Um...it is an ad banner. This is not a banner to be used by d-addicts.com these are gonna be banners that other people might like to use when they want to link to d-addicts.com.BT-Slut wrote:Ruro, I'd like to suggest that the final version used NOT be an animated gif. It's too intrusive and feels too much like an ad banner. It's very distracting to focus on what you want to look/read when there's this dance/flashing banner above.
I'd also like to suggest that the final version used not have actors/actresses in it. Otherwise it ends up looking like another fangirl/fanboy spamming banner advertising for their favorite actor/actress/drama series. The final banner used for the site should be as neutral as possible.
I see. That makes more sense then. Animate and flash them to death then!
Oh so that's what a lot of people thought! Yeah, they're going to be used on other people's websites to link them to this place. Like the fs seeders or yesasia buttons on top. We should probably pick a few different sizes so that people can choose which ones they want on their site.
Great job, everyone! This was tough but I narrowed my picks, in no particular order:
yomychan
puccakiss79
techie
tracy
starliteddr3mer
kaitler
I'm really curious...who is this person?
BlueMiruku
I looooveee this one. However did you make such a cool gif?!
That scene of SSH with that lolli I could stare at it all day.
Great job, everyone! This was tough but I narrowed my picks, in no particular order:
yomychan
puccakiss79
techie
tracy
starliteddr3mer
kaitler
I'm really curious...who is this person?
BlueMiruku
I looooveee this one. However did you make such a cool gif?!
That scene of SSH with that lolli I could stare at it all day.
man! it WAS difficult to choose. everyone had some great entries. there were some with multiple great entries, too!
animetama:
awesome caption!
puccakiss79:
another great caption with nice simple graphics
ShaolinMunky:
(the font you used made the 'd-addicts' a little hard to read, but who can beat that many captions?)
NatNat:
humor and great animation
BlueMiruku:
this one, or one of your animated ones
Kaitler:
nice and simple
Pale-Mun:
gotta love that font!
starlitdreamer:
a nice simple one
zaza_tk87:
liked the use of the stars, but can't see the middle one
osora:
just funny (tied with neon's, but her's was just a little too outrageous!)
animetama:
awesome caption!
puccakiss79:
another great caption with nice simple graphics
ShaolinMunky:
(the font you used made the 'd-addicts' a little hard to read, but who can beat that many captions?)
NatNat:
humor and great animation
BlueMiruku:
this one, or one of your animated ones
Kaitler:
nice and simple
Pale-Mun:
gotta love that font!
starlitdreamer:
a nice simple one
zaza_tk87:
liked the use of the stars, but can't see the middle one
osora:
just funny (tied with neon's, but her's was just a little too outrageous!)
my pics
1
2.
3.
4.
5.
These are my picks didn't wanna choose ne with actresses or dramas as the main theme so as to take away from d-addicts. But i still chose #5 cuz of design but i wish the d-addicts was a lil bigger.
edited by iceberri: fixed the links for you. html tags don't work on this forum.
thx!!
2.
3.
4.
5.
These are my picks didn't wanna choose ne with actresses or dramas as the main theme so as to take away from d-addicts. But i still chose #5 cuz of design but i wish the d-addicts was a lil bigger.
edited by iceberri: fixed the links for you. html tags don't work on this forum.
thx!!
Last edited by aziatik on Jan 15th, '05, 12:05, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Fansubber
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Apr 20th, '04, 01:34
- Location: BC, Canada
- Been thanked: 2 times
- Contact:
Okayyy, I have to stop looking at other people's votes....dont want my own choices to be biased...
1) Kaitler--although with its bluish color, it might be lost around D-addicts' own BG color, hmn, it depends where it's going to be placed anyway
2) Artemis-C 8)L!
3)Yomy Chan--another great one...
4)Bluemuruku--oh my gosh, I almost skipped this one...
5)zaza_tk87-I love all zaza's work, but this one sort of summarizes all of 'em
6)puccakiss79-the colors and the slogan is wat really got me to pick this one~reminds me of valentines' day,
7) Bluemiruku-big SSH fan eh , it's more like avatar-material...but I like them
8.puccakiss79~even the banner has its own drama ~beautiful blending
9)NatNat-I think Nat's banners are all catchy especially her slogans , I would like to pick that other one which has great text animations "D-addicts, you are not alone, we can help", it sounds like one of those quit-smoking help hotline , guess I better stick with this one
ok, last one...i would have stopped at number 3, I didnt know voting could be this frustrating , but i would like to help the candidates as much as possible for all their efforts...so numero diez...
10) zaza_tk87 - this is one of zaza's first banners and it really attracted me the first time I saw it
Good Luck guys, some of u have extraordinary talents thanks for sharing them with us!
1) Kaitler--although with its bluish color, it might be lost around D-addicts' own BG color, hmn, it depends where it's going to be placed anyway
2) Artemis-C 8)L!
3)Yomy Chan--another great one...
4)Bluemuruku--oh my gosh, I almost skipped this one...
5)zaza_tk87-I love all zaza's work, but this one sort of summarizes all of 'em
6)puccakiss79-the colors and the slogan is wat really got me to pick this one~reminds me of valentines' day,
7) Bluemiruku-big SSH fan eh , it's more like avatar-material...but I like them
8.puccakiss79~even the banner has its own drama ~beautiful blending
9)NatNat-I think Nat's banners are all catchy especially her slogans , I would like to pick that other one which has great text animations "D-addicts, you are not alone, we can help", it sounds like one of those quit-smoking help hotline , guess I better stick with this one
ok, last one...i would have stopped at number 3, I didnt know voting could be this frustrating , but i would like to help the candidates as much as possible for all their efforts...so numero diez...
10) zaza_tk87 - this is one of zaza's first banners and it really attracted me the first time I saw it
Good Luck guys, some of u have extraordinary talents thanks for sharing them with us!
-
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Jul 6th, '04, 04:00
- Location: SO-CAL
- Contact:
1) Artemis did a great job on the graphics in this banner. I noticed how alot of people are missing borders (which "completes" a graphic in my opinion) and how alot of em are pictures cropped with scanlines/grids, I admit some of mine are too it's all good haha. - this one just really stood out to me the most. YAY for ARTEMIS!
2) This one really attracts my eye. It's nice and clean cut and it looks very "CLICK HERE!" haha. I don't know. It just seems so nice, simple, and clean. Plus, there's my fav. color orange Gooooo SNANIME!
3) I like this one alot - it's really cute and creative. Nice job Puccakiss79
4) Kaitler - I like this picture o/t Sangdoo cast lol. It suits the purpose of these banners very well.
5) Puccakiss79 - I love the images used. It's really nice and clean - beautiful! ^^
[/i]
2) This one really attracts my eye. It's nice and clean cut and it looks very "CLICK HERE!" haha. I don't know. It just seems so nice, simple, and clean. Plus, there's my fav. color orange Gooooo SNANIME!
3) I like this one alot - it's really cute and creative. Nice job Puccakiss79
4) Kaitler - I like this picture o/t Sangdoo cast lol. It suits the purpose of these banners very well.
5) Puccakiss79 - I love the images used. It's really nice and clean - beautiful! ^^
[/i]
as a graphic designer i have a different point of view regarding these banners, first of all i will post the banners and explain why i like them.
1. Yomy-chan
i like this banner for different reasons, the harmony and blends of colors. its colorful and dreamy yet the picture is strong and has an impact. the pictures shows our addict on both computer + drama, the tensed hands shows how hard it is to leave the PC since we have another bigger addiction which is the Asian dramas. yes, we are addicted to a dreamy different world, the world of Asian dramas.
2. puccakiss
i like this banner coz of the dreamy colors again. and the concept " Asian dramas for all seasons" is completely True! D-addict was always there to hold us all and celebrate the beauty of Asian dramas! (anyone denies?)
3. starlitdreamer
this is a very nice banner, he/she chose a nice picture also the fact that both characters are looking upward and smiling gives us the impression that we are still looking for more. teh picture is notheless dreamy and catchy!
4. yomy-chan (again)
just look how expressive this picture is! showing him as if he's wiping his saliva shows the idea that we are thirsty for more. (and D-addicts are always there to satisfy our thirst) she did well by cropping the actor's face, i think since its D-addict, so its drama at whole, we dont have to chose our favorite actors/actress and force everyone else to accept them. (sorry but no offense) just a piece of advice, if she change the slogan coz it wasnt very convining for me..
there are many other good banners...but i think some of them miss something, some chose wrong pictures/slogans..some banners looks busy and crowded.
with all my respect to neonkinpatsu i dont agree with you to show drugs or injection coz its misleading and gives a bad impression about D-addict and our addiction. as if our addiction is something bad..specially for parents who complain about their kids spending long hours in front of D-addict might find the banners offending..im so sorry neonkinpatsu im just pointing out at this side coz maybe it didnt cross your mind..
to all the rest, you did a great job! keep up creating nice graphics.
1. Yomy-chan
i like this banner for different reasons, the harmony and blends of colors. its colorful and dreamy yet the picture is strong and has an impact. the pictures shows our addict on both computer + drama, the tensed hands shows how hard it is to leave the PC since we have another bigger addiction which is the Asian dramas. yes, we are addicted to a dreamy different world, the world of Asian dramas.
2. puccakiss
i like this banner coz of the dreamy colors again. and the concept " Asian dramas for all seasons" is completely True! D-addict was always there to hold us all and celebrate the beauty of Asian dramas! (anyone denies?)
3. starlitdreamer
this is a very nice banner, he/she chose a nice picture also the fact that both characters are looking upward and smiling gives us the impression that we are still looking for more. teh picture is notheless dreamy and catchy!
4. yomy-chan (again)
just look how expressive this picture is! showing him as if he's wiping his saliva shows the idea that we are thirsty for more. (and D-addicts are always there to satisfy our thirst) she did well by cropping the actor's face, i think since its D-addict, so its drama at whole, we dont have to chose our favorite actors/actress and force everyone else to accept them. (sorry but no offense) just a piece of advice, if she change the slogan coz it wasnt very convining for me..
there are many other good banners...but i think some of them miss something, some chose wrong pictures/slogans..some banners looks busy and crowded.
with all my respect to neonkinpatsu i dont agree with you to show drugs or injection coz its misleading and gives a bad impression about D-addict and our addiction. as if our addiction is something bad..specially for parents who complain about their kids spending long hours in front of D-addict might find the banners offending..im so sorry neonkinpatsu im just pointing out at this side coz maybe it didnt cross your mind..
to all the rest, you did a great job! keep up creating nice graphics.
-
- Posts: 87
- Joined: Mar 19th, '04, 21:56
- Location: Los Angeles,Ca
- kali4niaguy
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sep 28th, '04, 19:00
- Location: :D
-
- Posts: 450
- Joined: Jan 22nd, '04, 16:39
-
- Posts: 20
- Joined: Jan 13th, '05, 11:55
- Location: CAMBRIDGE
- kali4niaguy
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sep 28th, '04, 19:00
- Location: :D
-
- Geinou
- Posts: 295
- Joined: Aug 22nd, '04, 06:22
- Location: Canada
Congrats to Puccakiss, Kaitler and Artemis! I think I voted for Pucca and Kaitler..but the Artemis one didn't look familiar...I think I might have missed it..but I would would've voted for that if I had seen it (maybe it was because some of the images weren't loading even after refreshing..) >_< Artemis won anyway! So congrats to you 3 great job to the other participants!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest